Chapter 5 Harp

 The use of social media in history has become argumentative, collective, and difficult to decipher the real from the fake.  The nature of many of the apps have lead the history corner of said apps like twitter to become unsustainable for productive discussion in the eyes of many.  This is not to say there are not resources available on twitter.  As I have mentioned previously in this class there is a great resource of Ukraine war footage.  This is a resource, and a strength to short form sites like twitter.  The problem and reason academics are leaving is because of the uncertainty that comes with this, as well as the wide spread use of bot accounts that make understanding a video or its context virtually impossible.

There is room in the history field for these unprofessional sites, and I personally think they are necessary for the pooling of raw information and unfortunately false information.  It should be on these other sites where a more long form discussion is possible that the previously mentioned information can be sorted and discussed as the wheat and the chaff to get a usable narrative. 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Chapter 3

 Chapter 3 was about digitizing the history classroom. There were four waves of technology advances that went through for classrooms. The introduction of this chapter leads off with lecturing. "In the 1980s, teachers were given access to a new type of teaching room: the computer lab" (pg. 80). This had an effect on students and helped focus they're mind on a new way of learning. The first wave was teaching historians to count and code. With this new wave there are three ways students encountered technology in classroom. For example switching classrooms, like classroom to computer lab. The second wave is Silicon Valley and "cool" teaching. This is showing students how to adopt new technology and connect it to engage in creativity and experimentation. The third one is method without math. This is about teaching students to build technology tools then teaching students to use those tools. The Fourth wave is a return to history. This takes computer approaches that g...
Read more

Chapter 4

 The chapter brought about the interesting concept that the overwhelming presence and level of opportunities made it paradoxically blinding.  The idea developed by the author here is that the immense level of skills that could be applied in the new age of history have left some people in a situation where they believe they are not contributing at all.  The author describes this problem by demonstrating that older generations of historians could look to solve their problems with guides or  broad scale help whereas the current generation needs help on an almost individual level due to the speed at which technology has progressed. I personally agree with the assessment made by the author here.  I agree that the example of the student and her call for help from twitter was an excellent barometer for the developments discussed here.  The author makes a claim which I agree with which is that all though the history department she studied under would tqatisionaly b...
Read more

Chapter 5

Chapter 5 talks about the rise and fall of Scholarly Blogs. These started out as scholarly journals which started in 1665, published in Pairs. Starting with the postal system then moved through to social media and blogs there were new virtual communities of historians that developed. This transformed a new era of Digital communication. With the changing of technology developments allowed historians to communicate in new ways and gave them new opportunities to share their ideas. This chapter really made me understand what an evolution it was to be able to blog. The second wave of blogging is writing together. Historians are able to work together, giving different outlooks, and breaking down some challenges that they were not able to do before this. Blogging has led to new ideas and new voices in the study of history. 
Read more